Skip to main content

Stone Tiles vs Stone Look Tiles: Everything You Need to Know

When it comes to choosing the right tile for your designs, the beauty and elegance of stone often come to mind. However, in the world of interior design, you're faced with the decision between authentic stone tiles and their doppelgänger, stone look tiles. Both have their own set of benefits and can dramatically alter the aesthetics of a space. But which one should you go for? Let's delve into the world of stone tiles versus stone look tiles and everything you need to know to make an informed decision.

Understanding Stone Tiles

Marble Stone Tile
Marble - Bardiglio Pillowed

What Are Stone Tiles?

Stone tiles are slices of mountain-born mineral substances that stand in contrast to manufactured ceramic or porcelain tiles. They are quarried from natural stone like marble, granite, slate, limestone, and sandstone, each with its own distinctive properties.

The Beauty of Natural Stone

Glazed Basalt
Magellan Fire Stone - Basalt Flamed

There's an undeniable allure to stone tiles. The distinctive tile and stone patterns that nature has created over millions of years can't be precisely duplicated. The veins and variations in color found in natural stone like River Stone or travertine give a unique look to every installation.

Durability and Longevity

Natural stone is renowned for its durability. When sealed and maintained properly, stone tiles can last a lifetime. This makes stone a popular choice for high-traffic areas and a smart investment in the value of your property.

Considerations Before Choosing Stone Tiles

However, there are some considerations to keep in mind. Stone is porous, so it can stain if not sealed correctly. It also tends to be heavier than stone look tiles, which could be a structural concern in some spaces. Additionally, stone can be more expensive, both in terms of material and installation costs.

Exploring Stone Look Tiles

Faux Stone Tile, Stone Look
Maurizio Bellagio - Statua Matte

What Are Stone Look Tiles?

Stone look tiles are manufactured to mimic the appearance of natural stone but are generally made from ceramic or porcelain. With advanced digital printing techniques, these tiles can achieve the look of natural stone without some of the drawbacks.

The Versatility of Stone Look Tiles

One of the biggest advantages of stone look tiles is their versatility. They come in a variety of sizes, colors, and patterns that can be mixed and matched to create a customized look. Stone look wall tiles can offer a stunning visual effect in a bathroom or as a kitchen backsplash.

Easy Maintenance

Faux Limestone
Porto Bouro - Cream Matte

Unlike natural stone, stone look tiles are non-porous, which means they are resistant to stains and moisture. This makes them an excellent option for areas like the kitchen or bathroom where spills are common. They require less maintenance and are easier to clean.

Cost-Effective Solution

For those on a budget, stone look tiles are generally more affordable than natural stone. They also tend to be lighter, which could reduce installation costs and time.

Comparison: Stone Tiles vs Stone Look Tiles

When comparing stone tiles to stone look tiles, it's essential to consider your lifestyle, budget, and the function of the space you're renovating.

Aesthetics

In terms of aesthetics, nothing beats the authentic charm and variation of natural stone. However, stone look tiles can come very close, and for some, the difference is negligible especially when considering the cost benefits.

Durability and Maintenance

Natural stone requires more upkeep to maintain its beauty, while stone look tiles offer resilience and easy care. Both are durable options, but the longevity of natural stone can be a significant advantage if maintained well.

Cost

Budget is often a deciding factor. If you love the look of stone but need to keep costs down, stone look tiles can provide a similar aesthetic at a fraction of the price.

Installation

At Design and Direct source, we always recommend professional installation, but especially with natural stone- due to it's weight and the need for sealing. 

Best Use Cases for Each Tile Type

Stone Kitchen Tile

For a kitchen, natural stone can provide a luxurious and high-end look. But if you're a frequent cook and concerned about stains, stone look tiles might be a better option due to their stain resistance.

Stone Look Wall Tiles

Stone look wall tiles can add an accent to any room without the need for the intense maintenance that natural stone might require. They're perfect for creating a focal point, such as a feature wall or fireplace surround.

The Environmental Impact

Marble Stone
Marble - Gris Goleta Pillowed

It's also important to consider the environmental impact of your tile choice. Quarrying for natural stone can be resource-intensive, whereas the production of stone look tiles, especially those made from recycled materials, can have a smaller carbon footprint.

Making Your Selection

When deciding between stone tiles and stone look tiles, consider the following steps:

  1. Evaluate the space: Determine the function of the space and the kind of traffic it will see.
  2. Set a budget: Be realistic about what you can afford, not just for the tiles themselves but for installation and maintenance as well.
  3. Sample tiles: Get samples of both natural stone and stone look tiles to see how they look in your space and with your lighting. Contact samples@designanddirectsource.com for recommendations. 
  4. Consider long-term care: Are you willing to invest time and money into maintaining natural stone, or would you prefer the ease of stone look tiles?

Conclusion

Both stone tiles and stone look tiles have their place in design. The right choice depends on your personal preferences, the intended use of the space, and your budget. Whether you opt for the authenticity of river stone or granite, or the practicality and affordability of stone look porcelain or ceramic tiles, both can enhance the beauty of your designs. Take the time to weigh the pros and the cons, and you'll be sure to make a decision that you'll be happy with for years to come.


Back to Blog